Current:Home > ScamsKansas court’s reversal of a kidnapping conviction prompts a call for a new legal rule -Aspire Money Growth
Kansas court’s reversal of a kidnapping conviction prompts a call for a new legal rule
View
Date:2025-04-16 03:19:29
TOPEKA, Kan. (AP) — Three members of the Kansas Supreme Court want to make it easier for prosecutors to convict defendants of kidnapping, saying in a dissenting opinion Friday that the court should abandon a legal rule it has used for nearly 50 years in reviewing criminal cases.
The court issued a 4-3 decision in the case of a Finney County man convicted of aggravated kidnapping, aggravated rape and aggravated sodomy over a December 2018 attack on a woman in her home. While the court upheld Michael Wayne Couch’s other convictions, it reversed his kidnapping conviction.
The majority invoked a rule imposed in a 1976 decision that similarly involved multiple crimes. In that earlier case, the court declared that a defendant could not be convicted of kidnapping if the actions covered by that charge are “inherent” in another crime, are “slight or inconsequential” or have no “significance independently.”
The Supreme Court in 1976 gave examples. It said a robbery on the street does not involve kidnapping, but forcing the victim into an alley does. Moving a rape victim from room to room in a house for the rapist’s “convenience” is not kidnapping, but forcing the victim from a public place to a secluded one is.
According to the court’s opinion, Couch broke into the home of the victim, identified only as H.D., threatened her with a knife and forced her to move throughout the house. The majority concluded that moving the victim through the house did not “facilitate” Couch’s sex crimes by making them “substantially easier to commit” or helping to hide them.
But Justice Caleb Stegall said in a dissenting opinion that the 1976 rule is “difficult and cumbersome to apply” and goes against “plain and unambiguous” language in the law defining kidnapping as confining someone using force, threats or deception. He was joined in his dissent by Chief Justice Marla Luckert and Justice Evelyn Wilson, both former trial court judges.
“We have repeatedly recognized that the Legislature, not the courts, is the primary policy-making branch of the government and that it is not within our power to rewrite statutes to satisfy our policy preferences,” Stegall wrote. “In my view, vindicating these principles far outweighs continued adhearance to a wrongly decided and badly reasoned precedent.”
If a sex crime also is involved, a conviction in Kansas for aggravated kidnapping, or harming someone during a kidnapping, carries a penalty of at least 20 years in prison. Couch was sentenced to nearly 109 years in prison for all of his crimes.
The arguments among the seven justices in Kansas echoed arguments among U.S. Supreme Court members in a far different context in the Dobbs decision last year overturning Roe v. Wade and allowing states to outlaw abortion. Five conservative justices rejected arguments that the court should uphold Roe v. Wade because it was well-settled law, protecting access to abortion for nearly 50 years.
In Friday’s ruling, Kansas Justice K.J. Wall said the state’s appellate courts have long relied on the 1976 decision to decide whether a kidnapping occurred. Neither side in Couch’s case asked for it to be overruled, he wrote.
“And we have previously declined to reconsider precedent under similar circumstances,” Wall wrote. He was joined in the majority by Justices Dan Biles, Eric Rosen and Melissa Standridge. Rosen is a former trial court judge.
___
Follow John Hanna on Twitter: https://twitter.com/apjdhanna
veryGood! (56114)
Related
- Head of the Federal Aviation Administration to resign, allowing Trump to pick his successor
- Pearl Jam postpones Indiana concert 'due to illness': 'We wish there was another way around it'
- Jennifer Garner's Trainer Wants You to Do This in the Gym
- Coco Gauff's maturity, slow-and-steady climb pays off with first Grand Slam title
- Former Syrian official arrested in California who oversaw prison charged with torture
- Sri Lanka’s president will appoint a committee to probe allegations of complicity in 2019 bombings
- GOP threat to impeach a Wisconsin Supreme Court justice is driven by fear of losing legislative edge
- Ukraine: Americans back most U.S. steps for Ukraine as Republicans grow more split, CBS News poll finds
- Taylor Swift makes surprise visit to Kansas City children’s hospital
- Joe Jonas Addresses His Crazy Week and Makes a Plea to Fans Amid Sophie Turner Divorce
Ranking
- 2 killed, 3 injured in shooting at makeshift club in Houston
- Russia’s election commission says the ruling party wins the most votes in occupied Ukrainian regions
- Ja'Marr Chase on trash talk after Bengals' loss to Browns: 'We just lost to some elves'
- Tennis phenom Coco Gauff wins U.S. Open at age 19
- Military service academies see drop in reported sexual assaults after alarming surge
- The death toll from floods in Greece has risen to 15 after 4 more bodies found, authorities say
- A security guard was shot and wounded breaking up a fight outside a NY high school football game
- AP Top 25 Takeaways: Texas is ready for the SEC, but the SEC doesn’t look so tough right now
Recommendation
Could Bill Belichick, Robert Kraft reunite? Maybe in Pro Football Hall of Fame's 2026 class
Overdose-reversing drug administered to puppy after possible fentanyl exposure in California
Federal railroad inspectors find alarming number of defects on Union Pacific this summer
NFL Sunday Ticket: League worries football fans are confused on DirecTV, YouTube situation
Questlove charts 50 years of SNL musical hits (and misses)
Kroger, Alberston's sell hundreds of stores to C&S Wholesale Grocer in merger
History: Baltimore Ravens believe they are first NFL team with all-Black quarterback room
Michigan State football coach Mel Tucker accused of sexually harassing rape survivor